• 18 Posts
  • 25 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 10th, 2023

help-circle
















  • This is a terrible thread. The skip from the 11th century to the 20th is particularly glaring because it completely ignores the Qing conquest (as in empire-building, forcible takeover, war) of Xinjiang in the 18th and 19th centuries. That’s the time period when the term ‘Xinjiang’, whose English translation makes the colonial process even more evident, was coined! The thread then goes on and on about “separatism” (taking the position that the status quo political entity should remain whole for granted) and “extremism” (extremely what?) mostly by discussing the political associations of some Uyghur autonomist groups and otherwise using typical ‘war-on-terror’ talking points. I could go on but this is just one comment.

    The biggest problem with it is what isn’t discussed which is the power dynamics between mostly Han, mostly non-Muslim political authorities and recent immigrants (colonizers in this case) and their descendants versus mostly non-Han, mostly Muslim historical inhabitants (indigenous peoples in this case). People should do their own research about these things, starting from before the CPC’s victory over the KMT, and come to their own conclusions about what’s happening from a historically informed position.

    Lastly this is an opportunity for the local mods to clarify what counts as “hate speech, bigotry, propaganda, etc”. What guidelines if any are mods using to identify these things? To me this is plainly colonial propaganda, informed by anti-Muslim bigotry (though I don’t know if OP is personally a bigot, or really care).


















  • I’m noticing the same thing for some (but not all) subscriptions to communities on other instances. I’ll try retrying for some of them though, hadn’t considered it.

    Update: Not sure if I’m just lucky but clicking ‘Subscribe Pending’ then resubscribing appears to have fixed all of them.