Oct 30 (Reuters) - Reddit shares tumbled 29% on Friday, marking their biggest single-day drop and hitting their lowest level in over a year, after the company warned that Google’s AI-powered search was hurting referral traffic and could shrink its user base.
The online discussion platform still appears in Google search results but is attracting fewer clicks, as users increasingly rely on the tech giant’s AI tools for direct answers.
“When more than a million search referrals a week disappear because Google’s AI answers the question itself, investors are no longer looking just at the next three or four months, but at how much of Reddit’s audience it will really own in the years ahead,” said Vitor Madeira, senior market specialist at Capital.com.
Reddit warned that its daily active unique visitors could fall by a low double-digit percentage in the fourth quarter if referral traffic kept declining.
If current losses hold, Reddit is set to lose more than $7 billion in market value and Pinterest about $900 million. The two stocks have fallen about 44% and 23%, respectively, this year through their last close.
Reddit has a 12-month forward price-to-earnings ratio of 19.03, compared with Snap’s 7.53 and Pinterest’s 8.48, according to LSEG data.
Separately, Reddit on Friday said it has extended its cloud services agreement with Google through 2029, committing to spend $580 million over three years.
At least 11 brokerages cut their price targets on Reddit, and at least 13 did so on Pinterest.
Too many people block ads on reddit -> block the api -> people use google search and vpns -> block search and vpns unless logged in -> people use ai instead of search to find reddit answers because reddit blocks everything –> block access even harder -> complain no one visits the site anymore -> [we are here]
You forgot banning your userbase left and right.
Oh yes, I know of that very well. The admins have crazy trigger fingers.
Also, the experience of new users is just utter garbage. When I finally successfully sidestepped their detection of ban evasion (clear cookies + random user agent + VPN), I noticed how terrible the new-user experience is. I am supposed to gain karma to post anything, but I can’t get karma, because my account is too new and every post and comment is hidden or automatically removed. ??? BUT THE ACTUAL BOTS ARE JUST GIVING EACHOTHER KARMA! This bot prevention bullshit hurts only humans. Utter garbage website, it’s doomed, but I wish it’d die faster.
And canning my girl Victoria
That damn “better on the app” popup completely freezes Firefox Focus on iOS.
There are times where I search something, there appears to be a reddit thread with a descriptive answer so I tap on it, I scroll down a couple swipes and boom, popup freezes the app. Can’t do anything to make the back button appear after scrolling hid it. All I can do is force close.
On Firefox, Desktop Mode usually fixes this.
Have they tried making the UI shittier?
old.reddit, a clear example of don’t fix what ain’t broken
They’re appealing to a different generation users. New reddit users think old reddit is ancient outdated design. They like the new design because it’s oriented to the internet generation that uses mobile UIs.
It’s still not great on mobile.
All I get is a page telling me to login
Yeah old Reddit was locked up a few months ago. They don’t want people scraping and most new users use the ‘new’ interface.
You mean they used that as an excuse. The reality was probably that it was harder to monetize people using old reddit.
That might actually be an active strategy.
Making the UI worse so people have to click around more. Makes opportunity for more advertising, and makes it look like people are engaging more.
Never really thought about it that way.You say that…
I still use the app for 1 specific thing and let me tell you the iOS app (presumably their largest audience) is GARBAGE. And it gets worse every single release.
The latest release has a dead zone (!) in the list view. You’ll click a row/item and nothing happens. It only occurs after using the app for a bit and only in certain vertical place (about 20% down from the top). You have to scroll the list to be to click that item. Hilarious.
Of course all of this is on top the numerous other bugs.
Chrstian - ONE FUCKING GUY - made a superior app by himself. What did PewDiePie say, “it’s evolving, only backwards.”
I think it took them 4 years to get their video player working too. A video player.Their video player still doesn’t work
deleted by creator
Not only that, they’re mandating login. I think that was announced yesterday
If 80% of their advertising revenue comes from logged in users and they mandate login, soon 100% of their revenue will be logged in users. It won’t be more dollars than it is now, but they will have successfully stopped those other 20% from seeing ads.
Their whole philosophy is bizarre. Instead of letting a random from a Google search get lost in a series of recommended topics, browsing the sub, or searching for more stuff inside Reddit until they see an opinion they just need to respond to, they instead want to put up barriers to new user acquisition.
This is 100% to make it harder for non-paying AI scrapers. Their business is mostly selling data to LLM companies now. This won’t stop non-paying scrapers but now they will have to make accounts and it will be easier to spot and stop.
They are still shooting themselves in the foot by almost completely killing search engine traffic but this is their reasoning behind it. Once again a company killing their future for the quick buck.
The AI scrapers just make new user accounts anytime they need one. Requiring login barely even slows them down.
True. I used to launch Firefox in private mode to see if they had shadow banned one of my posts again (WAY too often, the answer was “yes”) and just about a week ago I could not do that any more and began insisting on a log on.
For other reasons, though, I’ve since committed a reddit suicide, insisted on a permaban (that was harder than I expected) and found y’all. I’m loving it.
Same, I’m done. I haven’t had an active account since the api bank. I was fine browsing old reddit on ff, but that’s gone.
Almost 20 years gone, I fucking hate this so much. They just couldn’t let it be with continual growth and now they’ll have nothing.
Whats the point to appear in google search, when you gonna lock your platform to have accounts to view the content… Just asking.
The real story here is about Google. Not only have they robbed websites of viewers with their chatbot answers, they’re making less money than they were with regular old search results and ads.
The headline should be: Not even Google can make “AI” work, instead the chatbots have made the whole internet poorer.
That’s an astute observation!
Every businessman knows, you leave meat on the bone for your partners (meaning be generally a good faith business citizen that doesn’t need to have all the cake) or eventually you don’t have partners and you don’t have business either, because your greed has razed the ecosystem.
What I wonder is whether Google’s ad revenue was doomed or not.
It seems like they shot themselves in the foot by having a LLM answer when you did a basic web search instead of just showing the websites. But, my guess is that they think that nobody wants that, and that if they only offered old-style search all their customers would switch to using OpenAI or Anthropic’s “web search”. At least by offering LLM garbage themselves, some people are still searching on Google, so there’s a chance they’ll see an ad.
I don’t know. I am not a normal user, and I’m out of touch with what normal people want. I have things set up so a firefox dynamic bookmark / keyword search thing uses the “udm=14” trick to go straight to the “web” tab in the Google results and not show the AI overview. But, I’m probably among only 0.001% of users who have done something like that.
70 to go!
Don’t listen to them Reddit!
They just want to stop you WINNING - keep going where you’re going.
Well deserved, that site has turned into an absolute cesspool of gender wars and Russian bots. It’s genuinely so hard to use now.
Content is terrible too. I guess when the bots learn from bots, that’s what you get.
More than half the posts are all reposts too
Comments too. I started seeing things that I had written years ago being reposted word for word. I assume half the bots were set up by Reddit themselves.
I mean…
But hey, at least here I can get that without a publicly traded, multi-billion-dollar corporation helmed by a technofascist.
What’s really annoying is that /r/all used to be all posts from around the world, not whatever’s popular locally. Now the only equivalent to that keeps trying to show me local stuff that I don’t care about. I’m sure if I was willing to have an account I could curate that, but I’m not doing that.
But, even with that forced local focus, India-related stuff is more and more popular. It seems to me that Indians are using Reddit more and more. More Indian users will probably end up driving off the more lucrative American userbase.
Funny how fake hype and bad decisions do that.
“a low double-digit percentage“ sure is a funny way to say 10-49%, and that since it represents fully 40% of the possible values (also known as ”a low double-digit percent”) it is a worthless non statement.
Fuck you u/spez. Fucking usurper.
Reddit’s failure was inevitable; once capital exerts excessive control, it’s time for people to leave. Everyone has surely had the infuriating experience of being bombarded by trashy ads on Reddit often with no human customer support available to address complaints. It has become a hub overrun by bots and scams; when you enter a subreddit, almost everything you see is just bots.
They also don’t let people lurk anymore.
We really do need to get back to a tech landscape where evil ceos are shunned and their products not used. We have tolerated the spez, musk, thiel, zuckerburg, ellison, bankman-fried, elizabeth holmes, Kalanich (uber), baszuskis (roblox) types for way too long. They are all a bunch of mega pricks and their companies should pay a penalty for their being openly evil.
Good.
I enjoyed pre-COVID Reddit, where you could find all political stripes and religions, a virtual “melting pot”.
Today? It’s like Lemmy but with advertising. So much more homogeneous, and the moderators are deranged. Let them rule their dying empire with furry fists, have at it, it’s yours now
Reminded now, right before I left Reddit I was banned from r/pics for being a member somewhere that they don’t approve of, I can no longer recall which sub but it was lightly Republican flavored (my favorite political adversaries).
Why would they care? How would they know what the sub was intolerable without joining themselves? Why didn’t they ban themselves then? They were despoiled, like me.
Senseless. I haven’t visited since the login requirement, piss off
Today? It’s like Lemmy but with advertising. So much more homogeneous
Might have been a while since you visited it then, it’s getting increasingly absurdly right wing - mostly bots I’m guessing. Pretty much all of the main /r/all subs
Yeah I haven’t been there for a couple of years. When I left it was a Democratic stronghold that had banned The Donald. Not as hard left as Lemmy, but close.
My ideal place would be “neutral” with all flavors, but I haven’t found anything like old Reddit yet, so I am taking a sabbatical here for as long as I am tolerated (probably another week)
Your posts here get banned for anti muslim hatred and terroristic zionism. Hopefully it wont take a whole week for a siteban for people like you.
It’s like Lemmy but with advertising.
Especially compared to https://old.lemmy.world/
Lol. Rofl. Roflmao.
It’s still surprising to me that 2 years later, it’s still double the value it was when it went public.
There was never any believable story where they would go public and become profitable.
One would think banning their long time users and those who say fuck spez/Trump/Israel/MuskMiller punch nazis in the face would have affected their user base. Considering reddit was once one of the most liberal sites on the Internet














