I might take over one of these one-year-free hosted Lemmy instances on my server infrastructure, but I read several times now that Lemmy’s image hosting system Pict-rs is using a lot of storage quickly.

The server I could run this on is limited to 32gb ssd storage with no easy way to expand it.

Is there some way to limit the image storage use and automatically prune old images that are not user or community icons or such?

  • poVoqOP
    link
    fedilink
    12 years ago

    That was the original idea of IPFS, no? Just that they pivoted now to trying to sell you filecoins :(

    • Aode (He/They)
      link
      fedilink
      12 years ago

      I’m not against including an ipfs layer in pict-rs, but the complexity would go way up. Federating an image between lemmy servers would require sending the ipfs uri between servers via activitypub, and then each receiving server sending that uri to pict-rs. pict-rs would then need to decide, on each server, if the ipfs-stored image matches that servers’ image requirements (max filesize, max dimensions, etc), and if it does, then that pict-rs server would request to pin the image. I don’t know exactly how ipfs pinning works, but ideally it would only be stored locally if it isn’t already stored in at least N other locations. If the remote image doesn’t match the local server’s configuration, it could either be rejected or downloaded & processed (resized etc).

      Serving ipfs-stored images that aren’t replicated locally might also be slow, but I won’t know for sure unless I actually try building this out.

      • Cold Hotman
        link
        fedilink
        12 years ago

        How would federated posts look if the original server went down? Just a 404 not found on the picture and the discussion left intact?

        • poVoqOP
          link
          fedilink
          12 years ago

          This seems to be the case right now, yes.

    • DessalinesM
      link
      fedilink
      12 years ago

      Yeah I think so, but I have no idea how “trust” works in IPFS.

      In torrents, you have to explicitly be seeding that torrent: if you don’t want to seed the file(s), you remove the torrent. With IPFS I think people can just throw whatever in there.