• shalafi@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    13
    arrow-down
    4
    ·
    12 hours ago

    I find this notion that reading body language is bullshit to be weird and fascinating. Are people taking single tells and thinking they’re 100% useful?! Of course that’s bullshit.

    Watched a great video by a scholar who studies lying. There is no single tell that proves a lie. It’s a stack of behaviors that add up to making that call.

    For example, if I cross my arms, leaning against the wall, ankles crossed while listening to you, I’m probably resting my arms. If I spread my legs and stand up straight while doing so, I probably don’t like what you’re saying. Is that 100%? No, but it’s a strong indicator.

    Another: If a person smiles at you with their mouth closed, they’re often merely being polite. Full teeth? They probably like you on some level. Not 100%, maybe in the former case they’re hiding being sad or upset, but it’s part of a whole picture.

    I sometimes think the skepticism is from people on the spectrum who think because they can’t instinctually figure it out, or that there are exceptions to what they see as a hard and fast rule, then reading body language can’t be valid.

    • Soggy@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      6
      ·
      10 hours ago

      It ignores too many environmental and personal influences. There’s no blanket tells. You can definitely learn a person’s body language and know with high confidence if they’re lying/upset/tired/etc. but things like how a stranger holds their arms or how they smile are too easily influenced by other factors. Maybe their hands are cold. Maybe they’re self conscious about crooked teeth. Maybe they’re Japanese and have an entirely different cultural background about how to present oneself in public.

      It’s not bullshit on the level of handwriting analysis or astrology but it is something many people are overconfident about.

    • Agent641@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      10 hours ago

      There’s a former FBI agent called Joe Navarro who puts an emphasis on clusters of behaviours as indicators, rather than just one behaviour, and, like you said, indicates that a single event is likely just happenstance. His books are really good.

    • surewhynotlem@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      9 hours ago

      is from people on the spectrum who think because they can’t instinctually figure it out

      Imagine you’re a person who doesn’t instinctively get standard social actions, so you study people to learn them. You’ll quickly learn that the entire thing can be faked.

      So yes, it’s very possible that human body language can help you read someone’s internal feelings. Especially when that person is an idiot and doesn’t have control over their body. Or their emotions are so big that they have no control.

      But is it particularly useful to be able to read the obvious or be deceived by anyone with half a mote of control?

      • shalafi@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        9 hours ago

        Almost no one has that mote of control. In a given situation, given an understanding of body language, yes, it can be faked.

        How many people do you think have that understanding and the impetus to fake it? The vast majority of us are going through life with no thought as to what our faces or bodies are showing.

        One funny example, I’ve used body language to see if a first date is into me. It’s usually pretty obvious, to me anyway, but there have been times when I thought, “Surely this girl isn’t liking me as much as I think!”

        On one such date I was floored. I’d cross my arms and lean across the table, lean back and throw an arm over the booth, cross my legs under the table, stuff like that. She was unconsciously mirroring my every move! It was kinda freaking me out, and I wanted to pay attention to her, so I cut it out.

        But again, that was the rare occasion when I thought about body language and actively used it. In 99.9999% of my interactions, I’m utterly clueless, going on instinct. And in any case, only the best of the best can mimic every tiny tell they wish too. No one thing means anything, but they stack.

        Look at your favorite actor or actress. They’re not consciously using many clues, they put their head in the role and the tells come out naturally. That’s why they’re famous! (and unusual…)

    • Punkie@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      9 hours ago

      Even if you’re an empath, if the subject believes what they say, you won’t know the lie. Same with all these “tells.” The only way to catch someone in a lie is kind of a confidence game, they have to know it’s a lie, and cross referencing, And even then, it comes down to a guess. And suppose they have tells as “a lie?” You don’t know if it’s a direct lie, or they are covering up a separate issue. For example:

      “Did you murder that guy?”

      And they didn’t, but they are afraid of being accused of doing so, because they know that evidence points to them from a subjective point of view. Before the victim’s death, he was publicly humiliated by the victim, the victim was shot by a gun that he loaned someone else, who they know would never admit to it… They lack confidence in projecting the truth, so they overcompensate, which is a “tell” for lying. So, even if the perspire, stammer, act nervous… they still didn’t do it.

      Then there’s a second, more nefarious thing: the police don’t care really who did it, they just want a suspect, and it doesn’t ultimately matter as long as they can find someone to blame and get it done. So, “We could tell he was lying, he didn’t pass a lie detector test,” or whatever. Just if they can nail a guy, case closed, one and done.