exposure to csam, through self reporting, increases the risk the viewer will seek contact with children, in case you need more arguments against csam. I’ve heard the argument that AI generated images may be a harm reduction situation. it’s not. it’s incredibly damaging to the viewer if they are seeking it out, it makes them more likely to abuse, if they are exposed to it as victims it can cause lasting damage, much of it is just remixed images of actual child abuse victims, and that revictimizes them, and causes serious damage as well. We really need to stop pretending the companies that make this software aren’t responsible for this software.
You’re right. A video game is far more interactive. Heck these days you can even put on a headset and really simulate the action of murdering people. Grand Theft Auto is a whole detailed simulation on muder, theft, and more. Wayyy more immersive than just plain video.
Clearly then, by your own logic and the study’s conclusion, watching simulated sources make people more likely to do the thing after all. I mean, what sick person fantasizes about murdering strangers?
Obviously we must ban the existence of violent video games or crime in society will spiral out of control.
Edit: for the younger lemmings, this is sarcasm. “Fake X causes more real X” is really old propaganda, and its usually used on something most of the population already finds morally objectable + is harmful to society to advance some ulterior motive.
In this case, probably government spying and the erosion of privacy, as usual.
your doing A LOT here, friend. I’m not sure I can unpack this… I’m not suggesting playing Grand Theft Auto is going to make anyone more likely to commit violent crimes. I don’t see the connection with csam. I don’t think the effects of viewing csam is equivalent or similar to playing a video game. I’ve played GTA, it’s really not an instruction manual or stimulation of detailed murder or violence, honestly, it’s a bit silly and while modern versions of the game are more detailed than the early versions of the game that were graphically more similar to Frogger than anything else, it’s still not very detailed. if you needed a murder equivalent to csam I think gore and ‘faces of death’ type of videos would be more comparable, video games are marketed to be fun and are rated and regulated pretty heavily in most areas of the world, AI generated csam isn’t being caught up in that same process of regulation or review, multiple corporations have made software that is producing AI generated csam and no one is really holding them accountable like you or me would be if we personally increased the reported rates of csam by huge orders of magnitude. we’d be in prison. the software isn’t free from the corporations that made it. they made it, they should be held accountable.
This study explores a sample of 1,546 anonymous individuals
I have a study of 23023012301230123050503450 anonymous individuals, of which 78% agreed that you smell like doo doo. Yep. True story. If you disagree, you hate science. How could you do this?
I shouldn’t be this sarcastic, the journal is called " Journal of Online Trust and Safety (JOTS) " with a name like that, how could I ever be so arrogant to not believe 1546 anonymous individuals on the internet? Shame on me, really.
Agreed, studies on this topic are always what someone on the other end wants to hear. The premise is inconsistent and the conclusion doesnt hold. If this study was done about something less “taboo” it would’ve been lost and forgotten.
If my critique is directed at the quality of their output, their degree, occupation, education, etc. don’t matter. The output is still bad. Whether or not I or they have a degree is irrelevant.
The concept of csam exposure influencing behaviour is highly plausible.
The entire scientific community and publishing industry is a minefield. So is CSAM and the call for more restrictive governing of the internet.
The thing I know for sure is that there are people on this planet who have a political and a financial motive to lie and fabricate studies to justify their politics.
The thing I’m mostly skeptical on is the scientific process. Not because it can’t work, but because that entire field too, has bad incentives. “Reputation” is held up, frankly, by boomers who have trouble operating a printer, but did some important theoretical work before the internet was made public and by politics and a disinterested public that doesn’t apply scrutiny to what their “intellectual elite” is actually doing.
The internet is a KNOWN source of bad information. Those 1546 “anonymous individuals” could be one bored 4chan user, or one chinese/russian/us spy agency worker justifying the next expansion of their budget.
is highly plausible.
Is not science. It’s guesswork.
I appreciate that it is difficult to collect good information on this subject, but that’s just how it is. Tough luck. As a scientist, a proper scientist, you don’t get to publish “it’s plausible” from a source you can’t verify as fact.
wow it sounds like you hate surveys and science. sorry about that.
my comment on an internet news article was that child sexual abuse material even if generated by AI isn’t a harm reduction, as it is shown to cause harm in multiple ways. if you want to argue that being exposed to csam as a viewer isn’t harmful to the viewer or doesn’t make them feel more inclined to abuse children in real life, that’s fine, you can do that AND hate science. it’s OK, man.
I’m not trying to get you to agree surveys and science as a whole are valid.
I agree with the plausibility of the concept, but anonymous surveys aren’t really something we should be calling a “study”. They’re barely considered evidence as they’re open to extreme errors, bias, and manipulation; especially by respondents.
Nice to see my comment get destroyed. I agree with all of you on the importance of being rigorous in science, and that self reporting surveys are not reliable.
The reasoning that made me comment was:
I think original commenter is making an argument in good faith. You can dismiss the study, but then at least argue the point? Surely everyone agrees that the opposite view – that AI generated csam could reduce harm – is insane???
https://tsjournal.org/index.php/jots/article/view/29
exposure to csam, through self reporting, increases the risk the viewer will seek contact with children, in case you need more arguments against csam. I’ve heard the argument that AI generated images may be a harm reduction situation. it’s not. it’s incredibly damaging to the viewer if they are seeking it out, it makes them more likely to abuse, if they are exposed to it as victims it can cause lasting damage, much of it is just remixed images of actual child abuse victims, and that revictimizes them, and causes serious damage as well. We really need to stop pretending the companies that make this software aren’t responsible for this software.
So why is this a different effect to video games and violence?
why would watching children be abused from real or stimulated sources be the same as playing a violent video game?
You’re right. A video game is far more interactive. Heck these days you can even put on a headset and really simulate the action of murdering people. Grand Theft Auto is a whole detailed simulation on muder, theft, and more. Wayyy more immersive than just plain video.
Clearly then, by your own logic and the study’s conclusion, watching simulated sources make people more likely to do the thing after all. I mean, what sick person fantasizes about murdering strangers?
Obviously we must ban the existence of violent video games or crime in society will spiral out of control.
Edit: for the younger lemmings, this is sarcasm. “Fake X causes more real X” is really old propaganda, and its usually used on something most of the population already finds morally objectable + is harmful to society to advance some ulterior motive.
In this case, probably government spying and the erosion of privacy, as usual.
your doing A LOT here, friend. I’m not sure I can unpack this… I’m not suggesting playing Grand Theft Auto is going to make anyone more likely to commit violent crimes. I don’t see the connection with csam. I don’t think the effects of viewing csam is equivalent or similar to playing a video game. I’ve played GTA, it’s really not an instruction manual or stimulation of detailed murder or violence, honestly, it’s a bit silly and while modern versions of the game are more detailed than the early versions of the game that were graphically more similar to Frogger than anything else, it’s still not very detailed. if you needed a murder equivalent to csam I think gore and ‘faces of death’ type of videos would be more comparable, video games are marketed to be fun and are rated and regulated pretty heavily in most areas of the world, AI generated csam isn’t being caught up in that same process of regulation or review, multiple corporations have made software that is producing AI generated csam and no one is really holding them accountable like you or me would be if we personally increased the reported rates of csam by huge orders of magnitude. we’d be in prison. the software isn’t free from the corporations that made it. they made it, they should be held accountable.
I have a study of 23023012301230123050503450 anonymous individuals, of which 78% agreed that you smell like doo doo. Yep. True story. If you disagree, you hate science. How could you do this?
I shouldn’t be this sarcastic, the journal is called " Journal of Online Trust and Safety (JOTS) " with a name like that, how could I ever be so arrogant to not believe 1546 anonymous individuals on the internet? Shame on me, really.
Agreed, studies on this topic are always what someone on the other end wants to hear. The premise is inconsistent and the conclusion doesnt hold. If this study was done about something less “taboo” it would’ve been lost and forgotten.
Seems to be run by academics
https://tsjournal.org/index.php/jots/about/editorialTeam
If we’re appealing to authority, then let me promise you that I too have an academic degree.
That fallacy doesn’t mean “nobody knows more than me”.
If my critique is directed at the quality of their output, their degree, occupation, education, etc. don’t matter. The output is still bad. Whether or not I or they have a degree is irrelevant.
So what? They can’t make mistakes?
reddit moment…
you can’t just dismiss an argument because the study is small. Sure it’s small, but it’s not easy to get large data on this subject.
The concept of csam exposure influencing behaviour is highly plausible.
The entire scientific community and publishing industry is a minefield. So is CSAM and the call for more restrictive governing of the internet.
The thing I know for sure is that there are people on this planet who have a political and a financial motive to lie and fabricate studies to justify their politics.
The thing I’m mostly skeptical on is the scientific process. Not because it can’t work, but because that entire field too, has bad incentives. “Reputation” is held up, frankly, by boomers who have trouble operating a printer, but did some important theoretical work before the internet was made public and by politics and a disinterested public that doesn’t apply scrutiny to what their “intellectual elite” is actually doing.
The internet is a KNOWN source of bad information. Those 1546 “anonymous individuals” could be one bored 4chan user, or one chinese/russian/us spy agency worker justifying the next expansion of their budget.
Is not science. It’s guesswork.
I appreciate that it is difficult to collect good information on this subject, but that’s just how it is. Tough luck. As a scientist, a proper scientist, you don’t get to publish “it’s plausible” from a source you can’t verify as fact.
Second guessing science isn’t anti-science.
wow it sounds like you hate surveys and science. sorry about that.
my comment on an internet news article was that child sexual abuse material even if generated by AI isn’t a harm reduction, as it is shown to cause harm in multiple ways. if you want to argue that being exposed to csam as a viewer isn’t harmful to the viewer or doesn’t make them feel more inclined to abuse children in real life, that’s fine, you can do that AND hate science. it’s OK, man.
I’m not trying to get you to agree surveys and science as a whole are valid.
I agree with the plausibility of the concept, but anonymous surveys aren’t really something we should be calling a “study”. They’re barely considered evidence as they’re open to extreme errors, bias, and manipulation; especially by respondents.
Nice to see my comment get destroyed. I agree with all of you on the importance of being rigorous in science, and that self reporting surveys are not reliable.
The reasoning that made me comment was: I think original commenter is making an argument in good faith. You can dismiss the study, but then at least argue the point? Surely everyone agrees that the opposite view – that AI generated csam could reduce harm – is insane???