I (24M) am kind of wondering if there’s a class of people out there who were effectively immune to patriarchal conditioning because they had loving, secure parents who told them that it was all bullshit and they went on to become loving, secure adults.

I fell for it because I had abusive parents who made me feel that my needs were a burden, and society’s “man up” attitude and contempt for male vulnerability reinforced that message. I was unable to trust anyone or find women attractive because I saw everyone as a threat and believed that they would all be hostile towards me if I revealed my emotional needs. Every instance where I saw men presented as the “strong” gender reinforced my fears.

I could not feel safe around others until I knew that men and women didn’t have fundamentally different ways of thinking and feeling, and to do that, I had to slowly dismantle every “fact” I learned about the “male brain” versus the “female brain” and the gender binary. I also had to learn about and accept my emotional needs, including the loving and emotionally vulnerable sex I wanted that looked nothing like mainstream porn.

Only now, after more than a decade of gradually shedding my Christofascist indoctrination and becoming a radical socialist, do I finally feel safe enough to experience attraction and the desire for romance. I just turned 24, and I started deprogramming at 13.

So, was there just a large contingent of people who never fell for any of this garbage? The male brain vs female brain essentialist nonsense, sex-negative purity culture, the gender binary, the lack of emotional intimacy in porn, and the patriarchal trash everywhere? How can so many people love and respect each other and be normal with all these ideas floating around in society, unless some people were highly resistant to them?

I feel like there are a lot of progressive people on Lemmy who are secure in themselves and always had it right. And they can just find love and make friends in a healthy way, blissfully ignorant of all of the people and ideas that belong on c/AreTheStraightsOK.

What are your experiences?

  • paultimate14@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    1 day ago

    First of all, “immune” is quite a strong word. I prefer the word “resistant to” patriarchal conditioning.

    I was recently diagnosed with autism, which may be a factor. Studies have shown that autistic people are more resistant to advertising. It’s the kind of thing where I was always AWARE of advertising and I’m not arrogant enough to assume that none of it works on me, but I am always shocked at how everyone around me seems so easily influenced by social forces and the quest for social status.

    I grew up in a lower-middle class family. My father had bi-polar and schizophrenia amongst other issues, which led to my parents getting divorced when I was young. My father loved me and wanted a relationship with my sisters and me, but eventually all 3 of us separately went no-contact with him. His whole family (his parents, 6 sisters, and their dozens of children) all pretty much abandoned my mother and her 3 children. So at 7 years old I was “the man of the house”, surrounded by my mother and sisters.

    My maternal grandfather was not a particularly masculine man. He was short and slight of build, probably from growing up malnourished during the Great Depression. A thinker, not a fighter. My mother’s sister had a husband, and they had two daughters, but my uncle was not a huge presence in my life.

    So I spent a lot of my formative years, including going through puberty, surrounded by mostly women. We were poor and I was an introverted nerd, so I spent a lot of time reading my older sister’s young-adult fantasy novels about teenaged girls becoming strong independent women, challenging gender norms. I watched my mother and older sister work on the car, take out the trash, lift heavy objects, etc. They survived perfectly fine without a male presence. My older sister is also autistic and is, by far, the most intelligent person I have ever met in my life. So when I heard other boys say “girls are stupid”, my reaction was to think the person saying that was clearly wrong.

    I still remember my father making casual sexist jokes. Some of it mean-spirited misogyny, some of it the chauvinism of benevolent sexism. I’m glad that I avoided a lot of that. My step-dad would later come into the picture and do some of that too, but I was no longer impressionable at that point.

    At school, I was not a competitive person. I did not do very well in sports. My friends were the boys who were the other nerdy outcasts, most of whom have come out as gay or trans in adulthood. I also made friends with the nerdy girls. I gave them space, treated them as equals, respected them, did not try to talk over anyone. I listened to the girls at school and my sisters at home complain about other boys, and I took those lessons to heart about how not to act towards women.

    I was not perfect. With my first girlfriend, I ended up filling the classic role of the “white knight” chauvinist. I paid for everything, treated her like a princess, tried to protect her from the world. That was also around the time when I became aware of the prevalence of sexual abuse around me. My girlfriend had spent her ages 7-16 being regularly raped by her stepfather, and a lot of our relationship was her trying to come to terms with that trauma. Her best friend revealed she had spent years being raped by a family friend. All of the girls I had been friends with when I was younger suddenly seemed to both find the strength to talk about it and deem me safe enough to talk to about the men in their lives who hurt them. My response was to run… literally, but not figuratively. I had been overweight for my entire life, was a 17 year old filled with hormones, and was suddenly surrounded by stories of people I cared about being hurt by people who bore a resemblance to me. Running was a way to get healthier both physically and emotionally. In retrospect, I think part of my treatment of my girlfriend was feelings of guilt by association. I wanted to try to “make up” for what she experienced, to try to throw some positive male influence out into the world to offset some of the evil. My intentions were good, but the methods and results were bad. I was infantalizing her and participating in benevolent sexism. I was not trusting her to solve her own problems, and thus was not leaving her any space to grow as a person. I was feeling guilt for something I was absolutely not responsible for. I made it about me in a way, which was kind of selfish. We were both young and made a lot of mistakes in that relationship. We went to different colleges and eventually she dumped me for someone at her school. I took about a year to focus on myself, reflect on the relationship and my mistakes, and to think about who I wanted to be in the future.

    I worked in retail in college, A lot of my colleagues were women who were taller than me. My boss was a woman shorter than me, but a former body builder in her college days. I also worked with women who were conventionally attractive and were clearly used to getting preferential treatment from straight men, and they were surprised it did not work on me. I worked with men who were assholes and men who were kind. Tall, short, gay, straight, mean, nice, man, woman, black, white. I saw every combination imaginable. Any time I started to see a pattern of behavior emerging, life seemed to purposely throw a counter-example in my face. Eventually I stopped paying attention to the patterns and just focused on the behaviors.

    My best friend during this period was a Cantonese man I went to high school with. He grew up with an “asian tiger mom” (his words, not mine) and a father who was demure and meek and submitted to his mother. I think he also managed to avoid a lot of toxic masculinity, and that was probably why we were such good friends.

    Another good friend of mine at that time was a lesbian. I used to hang out at the Subway where she worked and we would talk about women and dating together. Eventually we started dating, and we recently celebrated our 8 year wedding anniversary.

    When we first started dating, my wife made more money than me. I still made enough for my share of the bills though, so I was fine with it. We were both poor. We split the chores evenly. Eventually she became disabled, with good days and bad days. Dropped out of school, bounced around various minimum-wage jobs. I finished my degree and got an office job. After a few years I was working 9-5 M-F in an office and making $60k, while she was struggling through chaotic schedules of evenings and weekends, exhausting her FMLA at each job, and never made $10k. So eventually she came to me and said what we both knew - it would make way more sense for her to stop working and just focus on doing household chores. It meant tightening our belts a little bit, but we would have much more time to spend together. We bought more clothes and she learned how to do meal prep, so she could take advantage of her good days and mitigate the impact of her bad days. I continued to advance in my career to the point where I now make nearly twice the HOUSEHOLD income of our local area, so we are comfortable.

    We are both conscious of the stereotype we are accidentally enforcing - the husband as the sole breadwinner who is domestically incompetent, the domestic housewife who is financially dependent. I am very aware that our situation is specific to US, and that every relationship is different. I still try to take opportunities every now-and-then to do some of her chores just so I remember how. When we bought new laundry machines I made sure I knew how to use them. I have sick days and PTO at my job - she does not. So when she is sick, I step up and do more chores. I take a couple of weeks of staycation every year, and I use some of that time to take over chores and give her a bit of a break too. Part of her responsibilities include finding ways for us to save money too. She has gotten good at grocery shopping and thrifting. She keeps a mental map of gas prices at all of the stations in town.

    Beyond that, I try to treat people equally everywhere. One of my closest colleague is a black woman. I see other people try to talk over her, or try to go around her and ask me to make decisions that are hers to make. I push back, make sure that she is heard, give her credit for her ideas. I do that for everyone I work with equally - there are some other white guys who are probably also autistic who are just really quiet and meek who also get talked over. There are women who talk over men. I do what I can to make sure everyone is heard and respected.

    I’ve also avoided networks of misogynistic men. It could be that I’m autistic or introverted. I avoid large friend groups in general. I am not very socially motivated and quite happy spending a lot of time alone or just with my wife. But I pay attention to how other people treat not just me, but everyone else around them. So when I meet a guy and he starts making “wife bad” jokes, I immediately see that as a red flag and maintain some social distance. If I see a group of women picking on another woman for her looks, I also clock that as a red flag. I do not feel any obligation to put up with that nonsense in order to attain social status or power.

  • Unlearned9545@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    1 day ago

    My mother grew up with 2 older sisters and 5 older brothers and, while she was no tomboy, wanted to be doing to the things the boys were doing not the girls and was often jealous of the toys, sports, activities the boys got to do and was often denied. She would even borrow things from her brothers or steal toys or pants they’d put grown from being trashed.

    I grew up with one sister 9 years older and one brother 11 years older and I looked up to them both and was interested in trying the things they did and following in their footstep until I got to be about 16 where I kinds took the reigns and started doing my own things. My mom was always supportive. Ballet and scouts. Cheerleading and baseball. Choir and robotics. The girls were typically supportive e as often I’d be the only guy, but the boys would tease me mercilessly and call me slurs. One neighbour who was really into football I finally got him to stop calling me gay by telling him “you run around a field grabbing other men fighting over a ball and slapping their buts if they did well. I hang out with girls in scant tight clothing, dance closely with them and sometimes carry or throw them. One started dating me after walking in on me in the dressing room. Tell me again which one of us is gay?”

    I’m not nonbinary either but I refuse to be siloed into what I’m allowed to enjoy. I have long pretty hair and a beard. I like wearing black clothes and that includes leggings, skirts, or standard work jeans depending on what best suits the situation. When I cosplay the gender of the character is no concern, just my interest.

    My shoulder had to be repaired and the scapula muscles like to slide around causing pain. I’ve found the best solution to hold it in place is certain sportsbra’s. More comfortable, breathable, and cheaper then the medical support they tried.

    I’d agree a lot with your premise that I could be this way and have that childhood because my mom knew how it felt to be siloed and my dad was loving enough to support even when he doesn’t understand.

  • Jankatarch@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    edit-2
    1 day ago

    My dad did punch me straight in the face for having a girlish voice when I was 8 years old.

    Also mentioned once that growing up, he would regularly assign me “male” tasks to make me more manly whenever he thought I was too feminine.

    Funny part is that these memories didn’t even click as a problem until recently. I kinda just assumed every parent did similar stuff to raise kids lol.

    My mom was mostly fine except disliked the idea of me cooking to an odd degree? I think that was for other, unrelated reasons tho.

  • RBWells@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    2 days ago

    My parents didn’t really treat us differently. Everyone had to do their own laundry, everyone had to do swimming lessons through lifeguard training, everyone had to do sports. I can’t think of any way they pushed any sort of gender roles except clothes were different.

    Like rowansprig, I’m tall and like to be thin because otherwise I feel big in too many dimensions, but my brothers are also thin and my husband and ex were both around my height, I would not choose to be any shorter, never wanted that.

    I think my mom had read that less strongly gendered people were happier. She did have a continuous debate with my dad, who was descended from a family with money, the women worked jobs if they wanted to - one of his aunts was a lawyer in the 1920s. He thought gender no barrier to doing anything, but my mom had experience of discrimination.

  • I had a short stint as a teenager where I went hard into the airsoft community. There’s a lot of neat things there with the mechanics of the guns and aerodynamics of the bbs, but also a lot of problematic machismo culture. In hindsight a lot of incel culture too.

    Anyway I realized I was trans shortly after that and never looked back

  • melsaskca@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    2 days ago

    I had lots of girl cousins and a sister. I played dolls and hopscotch with all of them, as well as baseball with my male buds (and female cousins). So, I’m not sure.

  • andrewta@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    3 days ago

    I’m over fifty . I’m at that age and was born at a time where many didn’t give a shit about gender roles. It really came down to, do what you are good at. Put your best foot forward…. And…. Recognize that just because you want to do something is completely different from being good at it.

    In other words: if you are good with cars and good with your hands , then become a mechanic. We didn’t care. But if you suck at repairing cars then step back and let someone who is good at it take a crack at it. No changing or lowering standards.

    If you are good with kids then take care of them. If you aren’t good at taking care of kids then figure out who is and recognize that you suck at it.

    • shalafi@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      2 days ago

      55 here and I found the question a bit odd. My parents were neither great nor terrible, but at no point in my life did I give a shit about gender roles. Nobody worried if they were masculine or feminine enough, or whether their behavior or skills fit the stereotype, it didn’t come up in discussion. I know it wasn’t on our minds or we would have talked about it like we did everything else. All I can think of was some good-natured ribbing for wearing pink oxfords to work in the 90s.

      I’m worried that younger folks are struggling because they didn’t have the social experiences we did. I think they’re better people than GenX in a great many ways, but they seem wildly insecure and detached from social cues.

  • The Velour Fog @lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    edit-2
    2 days ago

    Long story short, no, then yes, once I started getting more agency as a teenager. Under my parent, though, deviating “too far” from gender roles was a hard no. Doing so would have been met with violence and further suppression. I got away from the abuse about eight years ago. I plan on transitioning when/if there are adults in the White House again.

    For now though, I’m just kinda laying low and masking a bit, because my workplace leans conservative unfortunately.

  • YappyMonotheist@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    3 days ago

    Maybe I’m misreading, but I don’t see how, for the average man and woman, being raised with love and peace will make them less “stereotypically” male or female. Most of these tendencies transcend ethnocultural backgrounds, they’re just imprinted on us like our more visible, physical traits. If you’re not a “masculine man” or “feminine woman” then yes, of course it makes sense that not being repressed would allow you to express these traits and feel comfortable in your own skin, but for the rest it would just mean they’d be comfortable being “regular” men and women.

    I’m not American so my parents weren’t that kind of crazy. My dad was unwise and immoral, unserious, horny and angry (and definitely psychologically fucked, he was on some bipolar meds he took secretly), but not stupid and/or insane, lol. And my mom is a lovely, loving lady… who was always the main breadwinner in the family, a very academically minded woman who at the age of 63 finished a third MSc just for the fun/ego boost, and probably somewhere on the spectrum (we both suspect AuDHD, but I’m against the medicalisation of everything so I told her to forget about labels). And of course she can’t cook because it’s not engaging enough and she loses her patience just boiling eggs, lol… she’s a lawyer so she just pays someone to do it! So it’s hard to go full caveman when my dad was the emotionally erratic, unwise and whimsical one and my mom was the moral, serious and hardworking (almost to a detriment, she just hyperfixates for hours late at night and gets it all done, even at her old age!) one.

    Don’t get it twisted though, men and women are very different, fundamentally. The more you grow up and live and interact with others, the more you’ll notice it. It’s a spectrum and not a binary thing (which is why some men might have a collection of more feminine traits, and viceversa, but it is the exception and not the rule), and the reality of our differences don’t mean it’s okay to be a misogynist or misandrist, that’s for the stupids among us.

    • sprigatito_bread@lemmy.worldOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      6
      ·
      edit-2
      3 days ago

      I probably should clarify this explicitly in my post:

      By “fall for” gender stereotypes, I mean that you feel that you feel that you have to change yourself in order to be loved and accepted by others to fit within your socially-assigned gendered box or think about other people in relation to those gendered boxes, rather than as individuals separate from any boxes.

      One such stereotype is that men are stoic and dominant and women are emotional and submissive. If you are a man or a woman, forcing yourself to conform to this stereotype to gain the acceptance of others will cause you to abandon your emotional needs:

      • If you are a man trying to conform to this stereotype, you forbid yourself from being vulnerable, asking for help, and voicing your desire to receive comfort.
      • If you are a woman trying to conform to this stereotype, you forbid yourself from setting boundaries, being assertive, and standing up for yourself and others.

      Conforming solely to one or the other is unhealthy. A well-rounded individual needs to be strong and vulnerable at different times depending on what the situation calls for. But under patriarchal gender norms, these functions are split and assigned to different genders. In a healthy, mutual relationship, both partners give and receive comfort, both partners have boundaries, and both partners ask for help when they need it.

      I am of the opinion that strictly adhering to this patriarchal view of gender is damaging and makes it impossible to be secure in a relationship, because you deny yourself a side of your own humanity that you need to feel emotionally regulated and safe. If you are strictly dominant and stoic, you will never be able to voice your vulnerabilities and seek care, and if you are strictly submissive and emotional, you will be at the mercy of others because you cannot say no to them.

      • YappyMonotheist@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        3 days ago

        Very informative and thorough post, thank you for your reply. 👍

        I agree with the notion that acting wisely/appropriately means sometimes you have to pull and other times you have to push, regardless of which one comes more naturally to you, and one shouldn’t restrict themselves just because.