In an attempt to better understand Lemmy I’m wondering if some of you can shed a light on what the deal is between.ml and .world. The history, any significant event or a betrayal, how did we all run away from spez only to come here and throw mud at each other?
I’m sure it confuses a great deal of Reddit refugees who just signed up with the largest instance because of (in my case future proofing) reasons.
I’m wondering how this historic feud came to be and how I can be called a “Zionist” just because of my instance, and they are called “fascists” even though I’ve come across some pretty levelheaded people from that instance too.
Please, keep it civil!
I’m not trying to start a fight or mud slinging, it would be good if several people could say their piece and nobody shame or attack them for it no matter how much you disagree.
Thanks
I’ll be locking this post, as I know for a fact that nothing but debates (which generate a flood of reports) happen with these .ml questions. I hope 197 comments is enough for you.
You can find info on .ml (and probably even .world) and their behaviour in other comms, such as !meanwhileongrad@sh.itjust.works.
!fediverselore@lemmy.ca (even though it is currently locked) also has some info, if your instance has the posts.
I don’t think there is any organized feud, as such. A lot of instance population is actually self-selecting. Ideological instances are common. .ml happens to be one of the bigger ideological ones. Unfortunately, they tend to support authoritarian narratives coming out of countries that like to invade their neighbors. Lots of russian disinformation comes from that instance in particular.
I keep some lemmy.ml communities on my feed because it’s refreshing to see news out of china that while likely propaganda, is at least not the usual flavor of propaganda.
There’s no specific instance wide feud between the two or anything. At a high level, .world is just the biggest Lemmy server currently by MAU and .ml is just the oldest and flagship ones run by the main developers of the Lemmy software.
Now, the moderation philosophy between the two differs a fair bit, which is where the rivalries and the bad blood develops between users. On most general topics you’d see very little difference, but as soon as discussion touches the Russia-Ukraine conflict, anything negative about China, and the Israel-Palestine war, the mods on ml are aggressively one-sided in their moderation, and consider anything that goes against that perception as hate-speech against Russia/China/Palestine even if that’s not what you are saying. If you want an illustrative example, look in the modlog at the ‘nazi apologia’ comment I was tempbanned from !memes@lemmy.ml for.
Still, as community and instance managers, that’s their right. There’s significant overlap between lemmy.ml, lemmygrad.ml where moderation is more overtly this way, and hexbear.net where users like to communicate with image macros more in ways that I think most other server members find annoying. Some on world don’t like that so certain users crosspost discussions from ml communities onto world communities. Some users call the ml folks tankies for their disdain of violence committed everywhere except where committed by Russia, China and its allies. Some ml users (and many lemmygrad+hexbear users) call users on other servers libs for the converse reason, excusing or not pushing back hard enough on atrocities and oppression caused by Western governments. Some users like to generalize these characterizations to every user of an instance, it seems.
Aside from high profile defederations with ml or world and some servers for various reasons, refederations, redefederations between hexbear and other servers, there have not been any specific incidents that have caused .world and .ml to grow apart. I think it’s fine to let each server have its space.
Thank you for taking the time to write this
It’s over blown tribalism imo. There’s a handful of accounts that are always fighting each other. The rest are just normal people.
It’s libs Vs commies on an instance level. And, with Lemmy being a Western online space, libs are more numerous. 👍
They’re not communists. They’re tankies: nationalistic authoritarians who defend police state brutality and “alternative facts” to spread disinformation courtesy of Russia and China. They’re obsessed with a west vs east tribalism and nationalism.
Also, I don’t think you mean liberals strictly, but socialists — demsoc, socdem, anarchists, whatever.
Anarchists don’t respect nation states or arbitrary class divisions, which clashes hard with tankies’ rabid nationalism.
i don’t see it as east/west tribalism or nationalism at play, it’s generally people identifying what they see as a lesser evil in the situation. when it’s not interactions with hostile liberals i see plenty of earnest discussion in these spaces, literally ‘putin is someone lenin would have had shot’.
for me if i’m referring to liberals it’s anyone with a reformist orientation towards capitalism. if people are pushing that then they are more likely to compromise on important issues if given any individual power
MLs share my analysis of capitalism and imperialism. i can have disagreements with them about organization and process while agreeing on the fundamentals. plus they won’t call the cops on me.
with liberals half the time i’m arguing about whether capitalism is even the problem, or having to point out to them that war is actually bad. that’s a much bigger gap than disagreeing about revolutionary strategy.
Having strong opinions about reforming vs overthrowing capitalism doesn’t make you a tankie. Apologetics for state violence and Russian and Chinese totalitarianism certainly does; just as defending Israeli wrongdoing makes you a Zionist; and defending Trump makes you a fascist, etc.
They’re obsessed with a west vs east tribalism and nationalism.
Having strong opinions about reforming vs overthrowing capitalism doesn’t make you a tankie. Authoritarianism and defense of state violence and the Russians and Chinese dictatorships certainly does.
isn’t this just the tribalism that you were just complaining about? every state is authoritarian and has plenty state violence, if i’m going to have issues with that it’s going to be with the states i actually live in.
not wanting to engage with propaganda narratives about state enemies from my own state doesn’t mean it’s automatically a defense of what other states are doing
No. I don’t care about any nation state, only about the badness of dictatorships. Tankies defend Russian and Chinese dictatorships in particular.
Interestingly, they don’t defend (and often even condemn) other dictatorships. This is a feature of their tribalistic ideology and a product of propaganda. Concepts like “state enemies” are meaningless to me. I apply moral rules universally to all people and hold their behaviors to the same standard, regardless of their imaginary nation.
One last thing. Russia’s favorite propaganda is that everyone lies and democracy is impossible because state violence is universal. They don’t deny their wrongdoing (the way China does), they embrace it with whataboutism. Saying “all states have violence” is meaningless. Of course all statehood is based in violence. Yet clearly Taiwan and China have very different approaches.
To whit, I have no rights in China. They could literally disappear me for this comment.
then we share a position that all states are bad; i have particular ire for ones that are outright dictatorships of capital. that includes the US, all of its allies and some of its enemies.
i live in the US, so i am going to be loudest about about what my state is doing internally and what it’s sponsoring abroad. i am going to treat the propaganda narratives it produces about its enemies with suspicion, and that should not be construed with ‘defending’ anything.
it often does though.
No you libtard! Marx wanted name calling and calls for slaughter of entire nations.
Remember, ever threatening and ever weak and disgusting enemy is the base idea behind communism.
deleted by creator
For anyone wondering just what the hell a “tankie” is, as usual this article sums it up pretty well.
🙌
“Tankie” is just the latest evolution of “pinko”. It’s a pejorative against communists. It’s that simple.
Be mindful that it’s often just a handful accounts that post this stuff.
Well, alright, it’s actually 36 accounts with the username “cm0002”, but you get the idea.
There is no ‘deal’
There are some extremely active and vocal users on .ml that have a specific view point that they feel is extremely important.
You will see that viewpoint expressed not just on political posts, but in the comments of seemingly unrelated topics.
It seems that .ml was defederated from world to keep some separation of that view point and other topics.
You are still fully free to join any instance you want. You can even find community here to post that content if you wish, but there is a more active and vibrant community on .ml for that content.
It seems that .ml was defederated from world to keep some separation of that view point and other topics.
.ml is still federated with .world
are you thinking of hexbear.net or lemmygrad.ml ?
That sub is ran by people with a serious agenda. Its like the propaganda farm of lemmy. The mods beg you to stop reporting outright disinformation and the users are argumentative for no reason and aim to radicalize people of both persuasions.
Schismogenesis: two groups that perceive themselves as rivals will tend to amplify and identify with whatever initial differences they have.
til
.ml is the old instance from before Reddit exodus and it’s full of tankies and the weirdest takes you’ve ever seen (cue replies).
.world is the new popular instance.
That’s about it. Some people read into it that ml users are upset that they are no longer the default instance and can’t control the narrative. While world just doesn’t care and keeps on trucking. Who knows.
deleted by creator
In the beginning there was lemmy.ml only, BTW no one mentioned it but the dev choose .ml because “Marxism–Leninism”. It is a far-left guy with far-left ideology.
When reddit blocked its APIs a few years ago, a lot of people went to “lemmy” and a lot of new instance were created, like lemmy.world, which is not far-left, so a lot of people joined it.
They chose .ml because it was a free domain at the time.
Lemmy world is probably owned by a corporation. Since they’re the largest instance, they can control the hot page. ML is ran by the original developers of lemmy. They are full of pro communism accounts. I’ll let you decide if that’s cool.
Lemmy World definitely curates (shadow bans) people’s feed. ML probably does too.
If you’re not that political, don’t worry about it.
Anything more on the shadow banning? I did catch my account being shadow banned on another instance (not world or ml).
I think the community would turn quickly against any big instance shadow banning folk. That’s what the tesseract mess was about.
Yeah, it’s been proven to me over and over again. I post a lot of politics and some never get seen. Sometimes it’s a lag in the federation, but a lot of times it’s not.
Also, I was originally with world and one particular admin, who is still there, was removing comments and also curating in the beginning. That’s why I’m no longer there. He sent some shitty messages complaining that I removed all of my content. I’m not the first to complain, but world keeps him. That should tell you something.
It’s disappointing. Most people would probably ever know. As I said, I post a lot, so it’s more obvious.
Edit: Right now, my feed is being stopped from seeing the second page or autoscrolling. I had to find another way to see this post.
Lemmy world is probably owned by a corporation.
No. It is owned by a nonprofit set up for the purpose. The person that started it brought on a few volunteers (like me) to help out. We depend on donations, and receive some recurring and one-off donations. Every few months or so, we post a short request for more donations as the donations dip below the monthly costs, and that seems to keep us going.
I’m not sure exactly what you mean by “curates” / “shadowbans”, so I won’t directly comment on that. But a large part of the reason I was brought on was to have another person looking out for spam and such.
- Non profits can still be owned by a corporation. Non profits aren’t magically the good guy.
- Since you’re a volunteer, I doubt you know the depths of it.
Well, okay, you can make up whatever you want to believe, I guess.
I could say the same for you, lol.
ML probably does too.
it’s news to me if it does, got any example?
I don’t. They are so militant about communism, that I wouldn’t be surprised. They might be just a more open sort of banning. I remember people complaining when I first got here that they were banned for mentioning Tienanmen square and other things like that. I have no personal experience. That’s why I said probably.
i will say that based on the people i’ve interacted with that have been banned from here, i am glad that i’m not seeing their posts in my feed. one example being the guy who cross-posts 100% of content from .ml to .world, having him blocked on all his n+1 alts means i don’t have to deal with duplicates in my feed.
from my experience usually people doing things like ‘mentioning tiananmen square’ are doing more than just that, often they throw in an insult while redbaiting or dehumanizing. they then go to rend their garments in their preferred hugbox about how censored they were by the evil tankies.
Yeah, maybe? I’ve stayed away.
i mean it’s up to you if you believe me or not, i’m just relating my experience from this perspective.










